Lightweight metal foam withstands high explosive round
By Matt Shipman, NC State
New research from North Carolina State University and the U.S. Army's Aviation Applied Technology Directorate shows that stainless steel composite metal foam (CMF) can block blast pressure and fragmentation at 5,000 ft/sec from high-explosive incendiary (HEI) rounds that detonate only 18 in. away.
"In short, we found that steel-CMF offers much more protection than all other existing armor materials while lowering the weight remarkably," says Afsaneh Rabiei, senior author of a paper on the work and a professor of mechanical and aerospace engineering at NC State. "We can provide as much protection as existing steel armor at a fraction of the weight -- or provide much more protection at the same weight.
This image shows the CMF panel after the test. The black marks are fragments trapped inside the panel. The image shows there are no cracks or physical bowing -- even after the frags struck at speeds of 5,000 ft/sec.
"Many military vehicles use armor made of rolled homogeneous steel, which weighs three times as much as our steel-CMF," Rabiei says. "Based on tests like these, we believe we can replace that rolled steel with steel-CMF without sacrificing safety -- better blocking not only [from] the fragments but also the blast waves that are responsible for trauma such as major brain injuries. That would reduce vehicle weight significantly, improving fuel mileage and vehicle performance."
For this study, researchers fired a 23-mm by 152-mm HEI round (often used in anti-aircraft weapons) into an aluminum strikeplate that was 2.3 mm thick. 10-in. by 10-in. steel-CMF plates -- either 9.5 mm or 16.75 mm thick -- were placed 18 in. from the aluminum strikeplate. The researchers assessed that the steel-CMF held up against the wave of blast pressure and against the copper and steel fragments created by the exploding round, as well as aluminum from the strikeplate.
VIDEO: Composite metal foam (CMF) panel, fixed on the left side, is exposed to blast wave and fragments generated by the explosion of a high-explosive incendiary round (HEI), upon the HEI's initial contact with an aluminum striker plate placed 18 in. away (on the right) from the CMF panel.
"Both thicknesses of steel-CMF stopped the blastwave, and the 16.75-mm steel-CMF stopped all of the fragments from 15-mm2 to over 150-mm2 sizes," Rabiei says. "The 9.5-mm steel-CMF stopped most, but not all, of the fragments. Based on the results, a 10-mm steel-CMF plate would have stopped all of the frag sizes."
The researchers also developed computer models of how the steel-CMF plate would perform. When compared to the experimental results, the model matched very closely. The researchers then used the model to predict how aluminum 5083 armor -- a type of armor already on the market that has a similar weight and thickness to the 16.75-mm steel-CMF -- would perform against HEI rounds.
The model showed that, while aluminum armor of similar weight to the steel-CMF panels would stop all of the frags, the aluminum armor would buckle and allow fragments to penetrate much deeper. This would result in more damage to the panel, transferring large amounts of stress to the soldiers or equipment behind the armor. The steel-CMF, on the other hand, absorbs the energy of the blast wave and flying fragments through local deformation of hollow spheres, leaving the steel-CMF armor under considerably less stress -- offering more protection against fragments and blast waves.
Next steps include testing the steel-CMF against improvised explosive devices (IEDs) and high-caliber, mounted ballistics. The researchers have already tested the CMF's performance against handheld assault weapons, radiation, and extreme heat.
VIDEO: Metal foam obliterates bullets.
The paper, "A study on blast and fragment resistance of composite metal foams through experimental and modeling approaches," is published in the Journal of Composite Structures. Lead author of the study is Jacob Marx, a Ph.D. student at NC State. The paper was co-authored by Marc Portanova of the Aviation Applied Technology Directorate. The work was done with funding from the Department of Defense's Joint Aircraft Survivability Program under grant number JASPO-V-15-03-001.
Abstract: Composite metal foam (CMF) is known for its high strength-to-density ratio and extraordinary energy absorption capabilities. In this study, stainless steel CMF panels are manufactured and tested against high explosive incendiary (HEI) rounds to study their resistance against explosive blast pressure and the resulting fragments. It is shown that the CMF panels were able to stop the imparted fragments of various sizes, with speeds up to 1,500 m/s, and absorb the blast energy without cracking or bowing. The experimental findings were verified using IMPETUS Afea Solver and compared to the performance of a conventional aluminum armor. It is observed that despite their similar mass, the depth of penetration of the fragments into the aluminum plate is higher than that of the CMF panel. Significant front petaling and bulging is observed in aluminum plate following impact of the blast and frags. No petaling and minimal bulging is observed in all CMF panels. In addition, CMF panels are far less stressed when compared to the aluminum plate at any interval following the blast. The experimental and analytical results are proving that novel CMF material can be the solution for the pressing need for lightweight and more efficient vehicular armors.